Marquee Magic: The Superstars Who Gave ISL Its First Global Pulse

globalsportspolicy
Jun 12
5 min read

Updated: Jun 15

Written by Tushar Baruah

A. INTRODUCTION:

When the Indian Super League (ISL) was launched in 2014, it promised to revolutionize Indian football. Cricket had long reigned supreme in the country, leaving other sports to fight for a sliver of the national spotlight. The ISL, however, came with a different blueprint—one that borrowed heavily from the razzmatazz of the Indian Premier League (IPL) and international football’s star culture. At the heart of that strategy was one key feature: the marquee player rule.

Every team in the inaugural season was required to sign a marquee player—an internationally recognized footballer who had played at the highest levels of the game. These were players who had competed in World Cups, Champions League finals, and top-tier European leagues. The idea was simple: bring glamour, experience, and global attention to Indian football.

Now, nearly a decade later, it's worth looking back at the impact of these superstars and whether the marquee model truly delivered on its promise.

B. SETTING THE STAGE: WHY MARQUEE PLAYERS?

In 2014, football in India was fragmented. The I-League existed but lacked wide visibility, sponsorship, and fan engagement. The ISL wanted to offer something different—something that could compete for eyeballs and investment. Marquee players were the ticket to credibility and curiosity. From a sports marketing and management lens, this made perfect sense. When a league is new, it needs hooks. Cricket has Sachin. Tennis has Nadal. For ISL, the marquee players became the faces that fans, broadcasters, and advertisers could instantly recognize.

C. THE STARS THAT LIT UP THE ISL

Let’s rewind to those early seasons and revisit some of the biggest names who graced Indian stadiums.

C.1. Alessandro Del Piero (Delhi Dynamos, 2014)

A Juventus and Italy legend, Del Piero brought not just flair but global media attention. Though his impact on the pitch was limited, his presence in Indian football was surreal for fans.

C.2. Nicolas Anelka (Mumbai City FC, 2014–2015)

The former Arsenal, Chelsea, and Real Madrid striker took on a player-manager role in 2015. His stint was controversial at times, but his stature made Mumbai a high-profile team overnight.

C.3. Robert Pires (FC Goa, 2014)

The Arsenal Invincibles star added sophistication and a calm midfield presence. Though injuries hampered his run, Pires was a hit with fans and media alike.

C.4. Elano (Chennaiyin FC, 2014–2015)

Arguably the most successful marquee player on the pitch, the Brazilian midfielder was instrumental in helping Chennaiyin FC win games. He later returned as a coach.

C.5. Roberto Carlos (Delhi Dynamos, 2015)

One of the greatest left-backs of all time, Carlos signed on as a player-manager. Though he played sparingly, he was magnetic as a personality and brought coaching pedigree from his Real Madrid days.

C.6. Diego Forlán (Mumbai City FC, 2016)

Uruguayan striker and former World Cup Golden Ball winner, Forlán, was a standout in terms of performance and professionalism. His stint remains one of the best in ISL history.

D. SHORT-TERM IMPACT: BUZZ, BRANDING AND BROADCAST

In its early years, the ISL became a household name quickly, thanks in large part to these marquee players. Stadiums filled up. Viewership on channels like Star Sports spiked. Brands wanted in. The league had visibility, not just in India but internationally. According to a TOI article, ISL's inaugural season reached 429 million TV viewers across India — numbers unthinkable for Indian football before 2014. For clubs, marquee players also meant better brand association. A selfie with Del Piero or Roberto Carlos could catapult a new franchise into national consciousness. It gave ISL teams a degree of legitimacy in the eyes of sceptical fans and investors.

E. BEYOND THE BUZZ: REAL INFLUENCE OR FLASH IN THE PAN?

Here’s where things get more nuanced. While marquee players created massive hype, the on-field impact was mixed. Some stars, like Elano and Forlán, made a tangible difference with goals and leadership. Others struggled with form, fitness, or motivation.

The criticism wasn’t unfair: some marquee signings were viewed as semi-retired football tourists rather than mentors or performers. The average age of marquee players hovered around 35–38, and injuries were common.

However, even if their boots didn’t always do the talking, their presence had ripple effects:

E.1. Mentorship: Young Indian players trained alongside legends. Imagine being a 21-year-old midfielder learning from Robert Pires or training under Roberto Carlos.

E.2. Professionalism: Many marquee players brought with them top-tier training habits, nutrition insights, and tactical awareness. These rubbed off on the teams and coaching staff.

E.3. Global Linkages: Their presence created international interest in Indian football. Some marquee players even stayed connected, scouting or managing in various roles post-ISL.

F. PHASE - OUT AND EVOLUTION: FROM STARS TO STRUCTURE

By 2017, the marquee rule was scrapped. The league was moving towards sustainability and competitive balance. The focus shifted to building strong academies, investing in youth development, and signing foreign players who offered more value and longevity.

This wasn’t a failure of the marquee model. It was proof that the model had served its purpose. It helped kickstart the ISL, and once the league found its feet, it was ready to grow up.

Now, Indian football is seeing players like Lallianzuala Chhangte, Sahal Abdul Samad, and Suresh Singh Wangjam come through the ranks, not because of marquee players but because of the systems that marquee players helped justify and initiate.

G. CULTURAL AND ECONOMIC LEGACY

The legacy of marquee players goes beyond stats or trophies. They were symbols. They helped fans dream bigger, made media talk louder, and gave sponsors a reason to believe.

From a sports economics perspective, they acted as loss leaders initially expensive, but ultimately helped build brand equity. Much like David Beckham’s move to the LA Galaxy, they weren’t just players they were strategic investments in long-term vision.

G.1. What Comes Next?

Today, the ISL no longer needs marquee players to stay relevant. But it can still benefit from smart foreign signings, not for name value, but for player development and tactical evolution. The goal now is not to bring the world to India, but to raise Indian football to the world’s level.

Still, for a generation of Indian fans, there will always be a nostalgic sparkle when they remember watching Del Piero glide across a Delhi pitch or Roberto Carlos barking instructions from the dugout. The marquee players may be gone, but their magic remains.

H. CONCLUSION

The marquee player era of the ISL was a fascinating chapter in Indian football history. It was a gamble, a statement, and a strategy. And like all bold ideas, it had its critics and challenges. But make no mistake without those big names in the early seasons, the ISL might not be what it is today. So here’s to the icons who brought their boots, their brilliance, and a bit of footballing fairy dust to India.

*The Author is a legal Scholar from Damodaram Sanjivayya National Law University, India

(The Image used here is for representative purposes only)

References: